Is ASPCA A Good Charity? The Truth About ASPCA!


The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) — not to be confused with SPCA which is a more generic term for animal welfare organizations and may not be affiliated with ASPCA, is a leading animal welfare organization in the United States, renowned for its commitment towards preventing cruelty to animals.

Since its inception in 1866, the ASPCA has been at the forefront of numerous breakthroughs in animal rights, working tirelessly to rescue animals from abuse, pass humane laws, and share resources with shelters nationwide.

But is ASPCA a good charity to donate to?

The ASPCA remains a reputable charity organization although they have received huge criticism in the past regarding financial misuse, animal cruelty, and bribery settlement. They still maintain a solid stance on their mission to save animals with the aid of public contributions, grants, and other revenue streams.

In this comprehensive guide, we delved deep into the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), a major player in the animal welfare landscape in the United States. We discussed their beliefs, explored their significant contributions, and highlighted the criticisms they faced.

What Does ASPCA Believe in?

The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA) upholds a central philosophy that humans have a moral obligation to treat all creatures with dignity and consideration. This ideology is not subject to the fluctuating tides of human sentiment, but rather, it’s seen as an innate right for animals, demanding legal safeguarding. Even as the organization has evolved over its nearly one-and-a-half-century history, this core belief has remained steadfast, guiding its persistent efforts to secure the well-being of animals through active legal enforcement.

The ASPCA is an unflinching proponent of peaceful methods in advocating for animal welfare. They ardently contest that acts of aggression or vandalism are incompatible with a cause that champions respect and kindness. This commitment to peace extends to their approach to animal abuse cases, with the organization pushing for punishments that reflect the seriousness of these crimes. Recognizing the frequently observed correlation between animal cruelty and other forms of violence, they advocate for sanctions ranging from fines to imprisonment, and counseling to prevent future offenses.

From its beginnings safeguarding the working horses of New York City, the ASPCA’s mission, as articulated by its founder Henry Bergh, has been all-encompassing, covering all creatures within the United States. Over time, while other organizations have emerged to protect specific categories of animals like farm animals, marine life, and wildlife, the ASPCA continues to advocate broadly for all animals, steadfast in its mission’s scope and reach.

Finally, the ASPCA treasures the symbiotic relationship between humans and animals, recognizing the profound benefits that this bond brings to both parties. This includes both pet ownership and the use of service and assistance animals. When evaluating whether animals are being treated humanely in any given situation, the ASPCA weighs whether their physical, social, and emotional needs are being adequately fulfilled. Their concern lies not only with preserving animal populations and species but also with ensuring the welfare of individual creatures.

How Does The ASPCA Help Animals And Pet Owners?

The ASPCA is aimed at safeguarding animal welfare through five core principles also known as Five Freedoms: ensuring access to nutritious food and water, providing comfortable living conditions, offering swift medical attention for illness or injury, creating an environment that allows for natural behaviors, and preventing fear and distress in animals.

Well, that’s just their mission, let’s delve into the practical ways ASPCA can be of benefit to pets around the world and every pet parent.

1. Promote Animal Welfare

The ASPCA is committed to promoting animal welfare and ensuring the well-being of pets everywhere. Through various initiatives, education, and advocacy efforts, they work tirelessly to create a world where animals are treated with kindness, respect, and compassion.

2. Adoption And Sheltering

Shelters run by the ASPCA are lifelines for homeless and surrendered animals. These safe spaces not only rescue animals but provide necessary medical attention, care, and affection until they find a suitable home. Simultaneously, these shelters assist future pet owners by offering a secure and ethical way to adopt, coupled with guidance and post-adoption support.

3. Disaster Response and Relief Initiatives

Natural disasters can have devastating effects on pets and their owners. In these trying times, ASPCA actively deploys disaster response teams, rescuing pets stranded or lost due to calamities. They offer temporary shelter for animals, ensuring their care and safety while efforts are made to reunite them with their families.

Furthermore, they provide much-needed supplies to pet owners affected by disasters.

4. Animal Cruelty Investigations, And Law Enforcement

The ASPCA actively collaborates with law enforcement agencies, offering forensic investigative services to solve cases of animal cruelty. They train law enforcement officials on how to effectively enforce animal cruelty laws, thereby creating a safe environment for animals.

4. Animal Welfare Grants

Gunding plays in advocating for animal welfare and ASPCA understands that. They claim that, from 2001 till date, they’ve funneled more than $200 million into supporting over 3,500 organizations nationwide including animal shelters, rescue groups, governmental agencies, universities, and other programs aligned with their mission.

5. Veterinary Care and Support

From offering routine checkups, thorough physical examinations, and administering vital vaccinations to providing helpful medication, the ASPCA is committed to the health and well-being of animals in need.

Also, animals who are victims of abuse or neglect can get healthcare and emergency medical support at ASPCA Animal Hospital. These hospitals deliver high-quality veterinary services at an affordable cost.

Their mobile neuter/spay clinic reaches underserved areas, providing essential and accessible spay and neuter services for pets.

6. Animal Poison Control

The ingestion of toxic substances is a common emergency among pets. In response, the ASPCA operates the Animal Poison Control Center. This service provides immediate guidance to pet owners during such crises, helping them take necessary steps to ensure their pet’s safety.

7. Animal Welfare Legislation

The ASPCA advocates for stronger animal protection laws and works to improve legislation related to animal welfare. They strive to create and enforce laws that prevent animal cruelty, promote responsible pet ownership, and ensure the well-being of animals in various settings.

How much of ASPCA donations go to animals?

It’s always a good idea for donors to do personal research and understand how an organization uses its funds to ensure it aligns with their expectations and values for its donations.

In a recent CBS investigation conducted in 2021, concerns were raised about the allocation of funds within the ASPCA. The investigation revealed that a mere 40% of the organization’s budget is directed towards shelter and veterinary services, as well as grants provided to local shelters. Additionally, the report shed light on the ASPCA’s substantial increase in net assets over the years. From under $62 million in net assets in 2000, the organization’s net assets grew to exceed $340 million by 2019.

As a non-profit, a significant portion of ASPCA’s funding comes from the generosity of kind-hearted donors who contribute to the cause. The ASPCA claims that 77% of its total revenue goes directly towards its animal welfare programs. Let’s take a deeper look at ASPCA expenditure claims:

A substantial 34% slice of their funding is channeled towards Shelter and Veterinary Services, underpinning initiatives such as animal relocation, facilitating affordable veterinary care for economically constrained pet owners, and animal adoption promotion.

Public Education constitutes 22% of their programmatic investments, emphasizing raising public awareness about the harsh realities of animal cruelty and aiming to bring about a paradigm shift in societal norms and behaviors.

Another 15% goes towards Policy, Response, and Engagement. This sector covers a range of crucial activities including disaster response, rehabilitation for animals who have suffered cruelty, lobbying for legislative change, and veterinary forensics, which are indispensable for successful prosecutions in animal abuse cases.

Lastly, Grants receive 6% of the funding, providing financial assistance to local and regional animal welfare groups. This allows the ASPCA to extend its reach and amplify its impact, further supporting animals in need across the nation.

While the majority of donations are used for animal welfare programs, of course, charities do not work for free. A portion of the funds also goes towards administrative and fundraising expenses. These expenses are a necessary part of running a large and effective organization.

Administrative costs include items like salaries for non-program staff, office supplies, and technology infrastructure, while fundraising expenses can include the cost of running campaigns to solicit donations.

Is ASPCA A Kill Charity?

The ASPCA is an organization that champions the rights and well-being of animals. They do not put animals down as a solution to minor issues like shelter overpopulation or the return of animals. They employ a range of extensive programs to ensure that the animals under their care can be rehomed or appropriately placed.

Euthanasia is viewed by the ASPCA not as the first course of action, but as a final resort when the animal’s suffering cannot be alleviated by other means, or if it poses a significant threat to the safety of the community. It’s a challenging decision made with the primary intent to prevent further distress and hardship for the animal.

Even though there has been some bad press surrounding ASPCA, they still pride themselves as a no-kill shelter. Out of 6.3 million animals whole enter their shelters each year, 920,000 are euthanized. This is approximately a 14% euthanasia rate. However, experts expect a no-kill shelter to have a kill rate below 10%.

Criticism (Bad Things) Surrounding The ASPCA

The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), a long-standing animal welfare organization in the United States, has faced notable criticism and challenges in the past. For instance, a New York Times article dating back to 1971 detailed allegations of inhumane practices and cruelty within the organization itself.

Critics argued that the method of euthanizing unclaimed and unadopted animals via decompression chambers, which the ASPCA claimed was the most humane method considering the large number of animals it handled, was unduly cruel.

Additional reports of subpar treatment towards animals, like puppies and kittens surviving the euthanasia process only to be discovered in a freezer, or animals subjected to poor conditions, neglect, and even cruelty by staff, cast a shadow on the organization’s reputation.

Further controversy arose due to practices involving stray animals, the cost of services, and concerns regarding response to calls for assistance. The ASPCA’s policy of charging $5 to individuals who found stray animals and called for pick-up led to dissent, as did reports of delayed or non-existent responses to calls for animal rescue.

The organization also faced accusations of mishandling animals during collection. The criticism was not confined to the public, with fellow humane societies expressing dissatisfaction with the ASPCA’s operations. Notably, Cleveland Amory, president of the Fund for Animals, stated that the humane movement would be better off without the ASPCA.

The ASPCA was faced with further scrutiny for paying a settlement of $9.3 million to Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus after it was revealed they had bribed the plaintiff to testify falsely that the circus was involved in animal cruelty. Shortly after this incident, came the resignation of the then ASPCA’s CEO, Edwin J. Sayres.

How many animals has Aspca saved?

The data you provided by ASPCA states that every year, approximately 6.3 million companion animals enter U.S. shelters, which includes about 3.1 million dogs and 3.2 million cats. Of these, around 920,000 animals are euthanized annually, while about 4.1 million are adopted, and around 810,000 strays are returned to their owners. This reflects significant improvements since 2011 when approximately 7.2 million animals enter shelters and around 2.6 million were euthanized.

Although your data doesn’t specify how many animals are directly saved by the ASPCA, the organization plays a significant role in improving these statistics. As of 2021, the ASPCA reported rescuing over 100,000 animals per year through its National Relocation Program, contributing to the nationwide efforts that have resulted in fewer animals entering shelters and fewer euthanizations.

The ASPCA’s work in rescuing, advocating, and facilitating adoptions, as well as returning strays to their owners, undeniably makes a substantial impact on the overall animal welfare landscape in the U.S.

Also Read: AKC VS CKC: The Ultimate Dog Registry Comparison Guide

ASPCA VS Humane Society VS SPCA

The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (ASPCA), Humane Society of the United States (HSUS), and Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) organizations all play crucial roles in animal welfare, but they function somewhat differently and focus on different aspects of animal protection.

The ASPCA, founded in 1866, is one of the oldest non-profit organizations dedicated to preventing animal cruelty. Based in New York City, the ASPCA provides direct services to animals across the U.S., including animal rescue, adoption, and sheltering. They also run spay/neuter programs and a hospital for animals in need. Furthermore, the ASPCA has a strong advocacy arm working towards advancing animal welfare legislation.

On the other hand, the HSUS, founded in 1954, operates more as an umbrella organization. While they don’t operate a network of shelters, they focus on driving systemic change for animal welfare at the national and state level. They lobby for animal-friendly legislation, run campaigns against animal cruelty, and offer assistance and training to local shelters and humane societies. The HSUS also runs animal care centers and sanctuaries for abused and neglected animals.

SPCA organizations, despite the similar name, do not necessarily mean it is connected to the ASPCA. SPCA is a conglomerate name given to all non-profit animal welfare organizations across the world.

Final Thoughts: Is ASPCA A Good Charity?

The ASPCA’s commitment to preventing cruelty and promoting animal welfare towards all aligns with a cause that many deeply care about.

However, like many large organizations, it’s not without its criticisms and controversies. Questions regarding the allocation of funds, handling of animals, and past practices do raise some concerns. It’s always important for donors and supporters to critically evaluate any organization they choose to support. Not all practices may align with everyone’s expectations or values, and the effective use of donations is a crucial factor for many.

Transparency and accountability are vital in non-profit operations. Criticism, while often uncomfortable, can lead to important discussions and, ultimately, improvements in the way an organization operates. The ASPCA’s progress and evolution over the years are a testament to its ability to adapt and grow.

In the end, the decision to support the ASPCA or any charity should be based on personal values, research, and an understanding of the organization’s mission and operations.

Thanks for reading!

Read related posts about

What do you think?